Can Introverts Plant Churches?

Can an introvert plant a church?  Or, better yet, can two introverts plant a church together?  Contrary to at least one person out there, I believe we can.  Adam McHugh has a great blog for introverts in the church (and is working on a book which I can’t wait to read), and he made room for some discussion about this on his blog a while ago.  (Thanks, Adam, for linking me a while ago, too!) 

Several reasons why I think an introverted personality is actually helpful for the specific new church development work we’ll be doing:

  • The cultures represented in the neighborhood of our NCD require us to participate in interreligious dialogue.  This requires a certain intellectual bent, for which an introverted personality is helpful.
  • Introverts prefer serious conversation over small-talk, and in a well-educated neighborhood (right next to a major university), serious conversation won’t be hard to find.
  • We don’t plan to become a mega-church.  Instead, our vision is highly relational and discipleship-focused, which means that we value deep relationships over many shallow ones.

When Eileen and I travelled through Chicago on our vacation in June, we stopped to visit Nanette Sawyer, pastor of Wicker Park Grace, another Presbyterian NCD.  As we talked about Wicker Park over lunch, she shared that she’s an introvert.  Wicker Park is small, and thus intimately relational among its members.  It’s not evangelically extroverted, but the Spirit is doing great things within the congregation.  From what we saw when we were there, it seems Nanette is able to lead the congregation at Wicker Park precisely because her personality was compatible with the personality of the congregation: contemplative and intellectual.  (Nanette, I hope this is a fair characterization – please correct me if I’m wrong!) 

My hopeful (but as of yet untested) opinion is that the key to being an introvert in church-planting is finding that rhythm of contemplation and rest that recharges one’s batteries, in turn providing energy for the more labor-intensive times of needing to meet new people.  It’s just the same on the congregational level.  A new church has to be “outgoing” in order to survive, but it also needs time to contemplate in order to solidify its identity.  This is why our vision statement includes “equipping” and “sending”.  They aren’t stages in a process – they’re rhythms of being equipped and being sent which the whole congregation will need to live into every day.   And if that rhythm is present, I believe that introverts can be very effective church-planters.  Now please pray that I’m right.

  1. mikegehrling said:

    Well, I obviously think you’re right. 🙂

    I think being introvert or extrovert is like any other nuance to a personality. Both have pros and cons to them, and people on either end of the scale need to moderate that aspect of their personality, lest they become one of the caricatures which that first blogger you linked to bases his entire argument on.

    As introverts, we do need to stretch ourselves a bit for the sake of evangelism. At the same time, though, if an extroverted church planter were to completely indulge that aspect of his or her personality, they would probably produce nothing more than very shallow Christians. In other words, church planting (and ministry in general) ought to push everyone out of their comfort zones at some point, whether introvert or extrovert.

  2. renee said:

    so… you think before you speak?


  3. renee said:

    lame humor aside,

    I think that this is the time for introverts to plant… we are in a time great cultural change. Religious thought is syncretistic. People are in pain. To find our way to the Way, we will need to be good listeners who interact with our current context, wherever we find ourselves. not some other time. place, or people.

    Grace & Peace

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: